“The funniest people are so sad!”
A friend told me that a long time ago. I don’t remember the circumstance, but I’ll never forget the words. Immediately Douglas Adams, a favorite comedian who drank himself to death, came to mind–definitely not archetypal happy person behavior. We may also think of the recently passed away Robin Williams, an actor who played in many a comedy.
Why is this so? It seems so paradoxical. If the comedian’s not laughing, you’d have to be a bit of a sadist to laugh at his jokes, it seems. Yet the comedians always are laughing. Funny people don’t make you sad! But on further reflection, one can see that Mr. Adams, Mr. Williams, and company are a rather sad lot. Why is that?
Allow me to answer the question with a question: what makes funny things funny? It’s unanswered, but let me direct your attention to the many theories of humor that attempt to explain the matter. (These are recognized theories, not like my unofficial and far more spectacular, but admittedly less popularly accepted, theories.) Many of these theories of humor are absurdity-centric. That is to say, it’s believed that absurdity is a crucial part of humor.
So comedians must understand absurdity, at least to an extent. That does seem consistent with observation…the class clown is rarely a super-conformist Sensing Judger. Let’s see what the negative repercussions of dealing with absurdity on a regular basis might be.
To illustrate, I’m going to introduce you to my friend, Bob the comedian. He lives in a culture that indoctrinates all its members to believe that the purpose of life is to count to 42. Bob has a great sense of humor and is good at cracking jokes. We’ll examine what happens to him after he’s cracked jokes for a while.
1. He starts questioning the norm.
Blind love of normality has its upsides. Bob knows that, but who doesn’t do a little musing now and then? Jokes bubble up from the subconscious, so it might not be entirely correct to say that he knows about the role of absurdity in humor. However, dealing with so much of it even on a subconscious level keeps the idea of absurdity fresh in his mind. With so many mad thoughts zipping around in his head, it’s hard not to notice how badly they match the norm. He therefore meditates on that. This leads Bob to step two.
2. Bob notices that the norm isn’t fundamentally different from his mad ideas.
This part is the crux of the theory: The norm is no different from absurdity–it is absurdity. Now, whether this be true or not (I believe it largely is), it’s a conclusion that many comedians come to. Not all of them do so, and not all of them say it, but spend enough time in the humor community and you will see the quotes that boil down to the whole world’s crazy. For example, was it a perfectly ordinary book where the Cheshire Cat declared that “We’re all mad here”?
3. After realizing the absurdity of the norm, a void appears that needs filling.
Acceptance of the normal value system is quite convenient. It’s normal in Bob’s culture to believe that you’re supposed to count to forty-two. Nobody in that culture has to worry about the purpose of life! Nice! Unfortunately, Bob now has to worry, because he sees that that’s absurdity just like a lot of other things, not necessarily a unique right answer like everybody else thinks.
4. Not all comedians are able to fill the void.
Bob doesn’t know his purpose in life anymore. He thought he knew; he thought he was supposed to count to forty-two and would then have fulfilled his purpose. But now he sees that that’s not it. What is? He can’t tell. He spends years trying to tell, but he can’t. It’s naturally depressing not to know one’s purpose in life. Bob becomes depressed, of course.
Comedians are sad because they must deal in the absurd. Dealing with the absurd causes them to realize how absurd the norm is, even though the norm answers questions that not every comedian can answer for himself. It’s only natural feel distress in the face of unanswered questions.
Please comment if you have anything to share, agree or disagree. If you’d like to hear any other theories, please let me know. 🙂 I’d be happy to oblige!